• Home
  • About Us
    • Our Agency
    • Our Team
    • Clients
    • Our Network
  • Practices
    • Crisis Communications
    • Aviation PR & Aerospace
    • Xenophon Analytics
    • ESG & Sustainability
    • Medicine & Science
  • Our Work
    • Media Relations Washington D.C.
    • Crisis Communication Washington D.C.
    • Public Affairs
    • Digital & Social Media Marketing
    • Strategic Messaging
    • Media Training
    • Social Media Training
    • Creative Services
  • XenSight Blog
  • Contact
  • Careers

A Masterclass in Crisis Communications

by David Fuscus
Mar 13, 2024
10 min read
A Masterclass in Crisis Communications
by David Fuscus
Crisis Communication

 

In today’s world where media can go viral in the blink of an eye, crisis communications can be the difference between fame and infamy. In a 2019 speech given by Xenophon Strategies CEO David Fuscus at The Jockey Club Round Table Conference, Fuscus delivered a masterclass on how to manage public relations disasters effectively. Read the transcript below to learn the rules of crisis management from a leader in the industry.

Introduction

Thank you, Chairman Janney. So, I work in crisis communications and management. It’s kind of an unusual line of work, and a lot of times, people aren’t very glad to see me. I appreciate the warm welcome I’ve had yesterday and today from everyone associated with The Jockey Club and this Round Table.

A few years ago, I was down at Delta Airlines headquarters conducting a training. During a break in the training, I was walking down to the restroom when the then-CEO of Delta, Leo Mullins, walked by me, took about two steps turned around, and said, “What the hell are you doing here?”

Crisis is an interesting line of work. In the past 25 years, I have worked across various industries and a wide variety of public-facing crises. As Stuart said, right now my company is working for The Jockey Club in press, social media and advertising.

But I will tell you, out of all the crises I have worked on, which is a lot, this one is the most personal to me. And quite frankly, most of them don’t get personal for me.  It’s because I love horse racing.

I like to think of myself as a competent handicapper. I owned a house for many years here in Saratoga. My two sons, Will and Chris, grew up here running around the backstretch and the boxes and delivering the Saratoga special. So, it is personal, and I’m proud to be helping the industry through these difficult times.

Today, I want to go through a couple of crises that are not horse racing-related to show you how they were handled, which can be applied to Thoroughbred horse racing.

Danger vs Opportunity- The Rules of Crisis Communications

The Chinese symbol for crisis is made up of two characters: one meaning danger and one meaning opportunity. Indeed, every crisis does offer an opportunity. They offer an opportunity to solve problems, enhance reputation and build credibility through the deft handling of the situation.

And some companies, organizations and industries come out stronger from a crisis. But many do not, and they leave a trail of lost public trust, of diminished businesses and unemployed senior executives.

Invariably, the reason for failure is ignoring some deceptively simple fundamental rules of managing a crisis and communicating with the public. Crisis communications is about how you communicate your actions.

In today’s world, you cannot spin your way out of a tight spot. Many have tried and many have failed. And the first rule of crisis communications is to end it. Take the actions necessary to correct the situation and then clearly communicate it to the public.

But all too often, corporations, individuals and industries don’t end it. They sustain enormous damage because they break one of these four fundamentals.

  1. Full engagement means the ability to shape the story, having the ability to define rather than be defined.
  2. In a situation where something is wrong, transparency gives the public credibility when trying to shape your own story and without it, you can’t.
  3. Responsibility means admitting you did something wrong or acknowledging that something needs fixing. Again, the reason you need this is for credibility.
  4. And finally, the most important thing is meaningful actions. Everything comes down to meaningful actions in crisis management. What are you going to do to solve the problem?

How are you going to do it? And do people believe in your ability to take those actions?

The Rules in Practice:

Let’s look at some examples related to cybersecurity and privacy concerns. Cyberattacks and privacy are in the news all the time.

It seems like every month or so we get news of a new one, a major corporation announcing the theft of personal data. Two recent examples are Equifax and Capital One, with both being all over the news.

It’s hard to imagine a company handling a data breach worse than Equifax. In 2017, they announced the theft of 143 million Americans’ personal data, which is over a third of our population. And this is from a company that’s trusted to protect our most sensitive data.

It’s a credit bureau, a company that is expected to have world-class security so this can’t happen. And when they announced it after the breach, they did a lot of things wrong.

  1. They didn’t define the problem initially.
  2. They let the story be defined by their missteps.
  3. They didn’t disclose the breach for six weeks.
  4. They gave very vague reasons as to why that happened.
  5. They didn’t engage with individuals; they simply provided a website.

Equifax told people to go to the website and check if all their personal information had been stolen. And then when they went to the website, the website didn’t work for four days. They gave little information – it took a week for the CEO to talk to the press.

This all gave the impression of a rudderless ship. They weren’t transparent with the media. They were vague about the number of people impacted and the types of information stolen. It took them two months to even admit that the information had been stolen in Canada and the UK as well as the United States.

And it took them days to announce the reason for the breach. And when they did, this is what they said, “The vulnerability was Apache, Stutz, CVE, blah, blah, blah.”

Like really? Anybody here know what that means? Because I don’t. 143 million people? Nobody knew what that meant.

That was their entire reason for it. And they had a series of self-inflicted wounds as well. Shortly after the breach, it was announced through some good investigative journalism that several of the executives had sold exercise stock options and sold shares between the time of the discovery of the breach and the public announcement.

Equifax came out before they finished an investigation and said, and I quote, “that the executives had no knowledge of the breach before their stock sales.”

Well, the chief information officer of Equifax at the time just went to prison in June. Two other executives have pled guilty.

Three weeks later, they announced a second data breach, an earlier data breach than the big one. But they gave out no information on it at all.

They didn’t have a plan or control of their public communications. Throughout all of this, they didn’t switch over from their marketing to crisis management on social media and we’re tweeting out things like, “happy Friday.”

It’s good. Half a third of the country doesn’t have their data, but it’s all good. And then, most notably, on their social media, they retweeted four separate tweets that were phishing links by criminals to try to hack people.

So, they are, you know, the gang that couldn’t shoot straight. The media was highly critical because of these mistakes. The slow, incomplete disclosure and other missteps set up a narrative and it set up the theme of the media coverage.

As the mistakes grew, the media coverage portrayed them as a company with a horrible security culture, which they had. The gang that couldn’t shoot straight. As an example of this, look at what Wired magazine, one of the premier technology publications in the United States, said about them.

“Three weeks since the company first publicly disclosed the situation, to a steady stream of gaffes and revelations, paints a picture of Equifax’s deeply lacking response to a catastrophe.”

That’s the media’s opinion of what they did.

And their missteps continue to this day. Anybody sign up for the $125 thing from Equifax?

Two weeks ago, they came out and said, oh, well, we’ve got a $700 million settlement with the Justice Department. Go to this website, sign up, and if you’re impacted, we’ll give you $125. My entire office did it. Everybody is out there going, oh, I got $125.

Well, a few days later with millions of heavy press coverage and millions of people doing this, Equifax came back and said, “oh $700 million isn’t enough, so we’re not sure what you’re going to get.” This was just another reason to lose public trust in Equifax.

Controlling the ship

Now, contrast the Equifax crisis with another major breach, one that just happened two and a half weeks ago, with Capital One Bank.

It was a 100-million-person data breach. They discovered it 10 days before they announced it, but unlike Equifax, they took 10 days because they were working with the FBI to identify and arrest the hacker, which they did.

They had a reason for that delay. And what did they communicate? They came out in their first public announcement saying they’ve activated the Capital One incident response unit. What does that convey?

It conveys we’ve got infrastructure to do it. We’ve got the ability to do it. We’ve got people to do it. We’re ready for it. We’re on it.

They had a good security plan. They announced that they had identified and fixed the security vulnerability. That it’s over. It was fixed.

They identified the problem and communicated that to the public. They said, “hey, the problem was a weak security on a computer that connects the cloud to the public internet.” And then they admitted fault.

And what does all of this give them? They’re communicating the responsibility. It gives them credibility.

And finally, they said that they’re going to individually contact 104 million people by letter. They gave full and transparent information to the public and the media.

So, if you contrast the two, you can go down the list of everything that’s there. But a couple of key points is that Equifax suffered from numerous ongoing self-inflicted wounds and Capital One was highly organized in its response. The media and the public viewed one of them as being inept and one of them as being able to go in and solve the problem.

Equifax is coming out of this with a severely tarnished reputation. When it’s over for Capital One, I can predict that they’re coming out of this with an enhanced reputation.

The postscript of this, just for grins: Equifax’s data breach was announced on September 7, 2017.  And on September 26, a couple of weeks later, Richard Smith, the CEO, “resigned” he retired, right? I mean, the board retired him. And then a whole host of the senior management company followed him shortly after that.

Closing Remarks

I can tell you that I’ve got an unusual job – I work in crisis communications. And just for a moment, whatever your job is, whatever your base of experience is, there are times when you’re in meetings and you know what needs to be done based on your experience. Right?

And I can tell you, I go into companies all the time and I am the voice of calm. I am telling everybody to calm down. You’re going to get through this, right? Maybe there’s going to be some damage done, but you’re going to get through this. By disposition and profession, I’m the calm one in the room. I am the most anti-alarmist person you will ever meet in your life.

That said, you need to act when a crisis comes up. We can’t wait it out. We can’t muddy the waters. Without unity and action, your credibility will be diminished or in other places, it will cease to exist.

If we do all of this, if we come together as an industry, negative perception can be termed. There is hope.

David Fuscus

David Fuscus

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts
Mark Hazlin
Sep 28, 2026
When Absurdity Is Strategy: The Rules of Humor in a Crisis
Crisis Communication
13 min read
David Fuscus
Sep 1, 2026
What Data Centers’ Reputational Collapse Teaches Communicators
Crisis Communication
7 min read
Pray for Damar Hamlin
Bob Brady
Jan 4, 2023
In Wake of Damar Hamlin’s Injury NFL’s Reputation Can’t be Helped
Crisis Communication
5 min read
Anna Hirst
Nov 5, 2024
Calm, Cool and Collected: Crisis Mode
Crisis Communication
4 min read
united airlines plane
Xenophon Staff
Apr 24, 2017
Bloody Incident Will Haunt United Airlines
Crisis Communication
4 min read
Xenophon Staff
Apr 18, 2018
Spot News: Southwest Airlines
Crisis Communication
1 min read
issue management principles
Bob Brady
Dec 11, 2020
“Monster Hunter” Film Producers Follow Issues Management Principles to Halt PR Crisis
Crisis Communication
3 min read
Bob Brady
Sep 11, 2023
Crises Are No Longer Abnormal, They’re the Norm
Crisis Communication
3 min read
David Fuscus
Mar 23, 2020
The Importance of Integrity-Driven Public Relations | By David Fuscus
Crisis Communication ESG Strategic Messaging
5 min read
Follow Us
Contact Us
Contact Us for a Free Consultation
The Latest
The Truth Sandwich
Nov 12, 2026
5 min read
Kelly Clarkson and Molly the animatronic bird
Three Birds and No Stones: Crisis Comms Lessons from Kelly Clarkson vs. Art of Play
Oct 15, 2026
7 min read
The PESO Model: 4 overlapping circles labeled "Earned," "Shared," "Owned," and "Paid."
The PESO Model in PR: Why the Media Lines Have Blurred
Oct 6, 2026
6 min read
When Absurdity Is Strategy: The Rules of Humor in a Crisis
Sep 28, 2026
13 min read

Contact Info

1120 G St. NW #450
Washington, D.C. 20005
202-289-4001

© 2024 Xenophon Strategies – No part of this web content may be used without the express, written permission of Xenophon Strategies, Inc.